FundRaiser Blog

The FundRaiser Software Blog is an excellent resource for nonprofit organizations looking to learn more about fundraising, donor management, membership management, and much more.

Why Appreciating Gifts of All Sizes Matters

Photo of plants expressing idea of slow and steady growthDear Kim:

We have thousands of individual donors and recently decided to stop sending thank you notes to people who give less than $15.  One of our board members heard you speak and said that you said everyone should be thanked, regardless of size of gift.  The cost/benefit of this eludes me. 

We have done a very thorough breakdown of costs in our development office and discovered that, when you factor in everything, a thank you note costs $5 to send.  When you factor in the costs of the newsletter and renewal letters, each donor costs us $12 per year.  I think someone giving less than $15 would want to think their money is being used for program and not used to thank them, thus using most of the income from the gift.  These smaller donors, while valuable for morale or heartstring pulling stories of small donors, are a drain on the bottom line.  As a consultant, you don’t have to worry about that, but as the head of development, I do.  Now I have to put out a fire with this board member who is all over me about the small donors.  Can you clarify your meaning? 

~Irritated in Illinois

Dear Irritated:

You may not believe this, but I have a lot of empathy for what you are feeling.  You are under pressure to raise money and may have little say in how the goals you are assigned are determined. Your office has done an excellent job of figuring out your “fulfillment costs.”  (Readers should note is an important cost to calculate as best you can, and that $12 per year per donor record is reasonable.) You have made a reasonable decision based on the bottom line, and other organizations with lots of donors have made similar decisions. 

However, I hope you will consider the following:

1)     Fundraising is about building relationships and donors start relationships in a variety of ways.  Some give $10 because that is what they can afford and we should honor that with a thank you.  But some start with $10 to see whether an organization treats its small donors respectfully.  I have had many wealthy people tell me that—they test with $10 or $15 and then give much more.  We don’t want to fail that test.  And, finally, $10 is one gift but not the only gift—a person could start at $10, go to $20, go to $10 a month, go to $1,000—we don’t know where the relationship will end, but we can bring it to an abrupt halt if we don’t indicate any appreciation.

2)    Studies show that when donors are thanked they are more likely to give again and to give more.  If thank you notes were not necessary, large organizations like yours, which are constantly trying to refine costs and increase income, wouldn’t send them.  You can experiment with this yourself. Randomly divide all donors who give less than $15 into two categories:  those who are thanked and those who aren’t.  See if your retention rate holds equally and if there are any other measureable differences between the two groups.  You will then have evidence on which to make a decision. 

3)    Donors who give small annual gifts are often the ones that leave large bequests.  Many people have hard assets they cannot give away during their lifetime but will give on their death. 

4)    Donors who give any amount of money (large or small) should be encouraged to give more and to give more often.   The first gift is just that:  the beginning of the relationship.  Think about making a new friend—you have coffee, then you have dinner, then you invite her family over to your family.  You talk on the phone.  Someday maybe your families go on vacation together.   The process is gradual and this is true of donors as well.

Finally, if you do stop sending thank you notes, you will not save the whole $5 you have calculated it costs you to thank someone.  You will still have to enter their information in the database, deposit their check or process their credit card, and decide whether to send them more appeals or not.  Your staff will have to look at the donor record to see what other gifts this person has made:  I have often gotten gifts of $10 in honor or memory of someone from a donor who may well give $250 or $500 otherwise.  Then you have to decide whether to thank the donor for this extra gift.  Sometimes $15 will come from a board member’s mother or a staff person’s cousin and that person must be thanked because of their relationship with the board member.  The time you spend trying to decide whether to save the $5 will use up a good part of the $5. 

At the end of the day, most organizations don’t have thousands of donors under $15.  If you never suggest that amount on your donor string and if you try to quickly move your smaller donors into monthly giving programs or offer incentives to give slightly more, these very small gifts will not be such a big deal, and the relationships you build with these and all your donors will increase your bottom line and your morale. 

~Kim 

Orignially published in the Grassroots FundRaising Journal . FundRaiser users can subscribe at a special rate of $30/year by entering is "$30" in the coupon code field on the second page of the subscription process.

To learn more about how FundRaiser Software can help you with your donor management

Sign up for an online guided tour

7 ways an alumni foundation improved donor cultiva...
3 Dead-On Grouping Tricks to Treat you right
Wait a minute, while we are rendering the calendar
operating systems follow up board members overview letter direct mail PayPal planned giving data entry campaign management how-to videos support SYBUNTS data conversion add ons Alternative Addresses donor engagement segmenting donors giving history Reminders donor prospects Codes appeal community supported gardens Reporting to IRS appeal letters charity golf tournaments annual maintenance plan donor contact information donor retention rate reports motivation flash sales membersip benefits major donors increasing giving amounts transparency advanced tab Cloud solicitors community arts nonprofits role of nonprofits donor slip major gift prospects budget mode code Crowdfunding Campaign relationship tracking pictures custom page community broadcasting Thank You membership programs Task List event management Facebook New Year gift entry Resiliency mailing capital campaign user interface GoFundMe project End of Year Letters raffle case study importing csv donor training tip holiday prospects upgrade product news memorial giving disaster relief Donor Portal NCOA processing word processor In-Kind gifts understanding giving trends mission driven Thanksgiving Company culture donation history thank you letters development director features training donor targeting fundraising letters change of address updating gift acceptance policy adding personal notes to letters legacy giving communications #GivingTuesday alumni Volunteer module donor profile donor attrition tech tip Excel donor attrition rate auction donor relations GivingTuesday Groupings user spotlights personalizing letters the Ask updates campaign Congratulations merge notes technical support anonymous donors holiday letters nonprofit fundraising vacation backing up data new donors ROI Network for Good happiness membership benefits letter templates brick campaign Importing Data customer portal donor advised funds pledges annual campaign donor retention new leadership salutation publicity materials online donations recurring gifts customer service general email fundraising targeted mailings tribute gifts animal rescue holiday giving banquet security government grants donor preferences donor recognition Personalizing spreadsheets upgrading donors Snow Birds welcome packet corporate sponsors FundRaiser Basic new nonprofit Facebook campaign new version National Change of Address in honor of donations lapsed donor building donor relationships grassroots campaign online donations foundations operational costs donor source planning gift notes field LYBUNTS grants spare fields large donations passwords moves management premiums office phoning donors accounting software entering auction gifts motivation code endowment campaign social media on site training Tickles volunteering repeat donors Constant Contact FundRaiser Spark arts donor loyalty ticketsales small donations giving levels how to handle auction gifts monthly giving tax summary letters merge fields correspondence correspondance texting donors look and feel password protection ticket sales new features volunteers FundRaiser Hosted data analysis announcements

Connect With Us

  800-880-3454 ext 3
  Email Us
  Request More Information
  Monday-Friday
      8:30AM-5:30PM CST

Customer Portal Login Form

   

The customer portal is unavailable. If you need support please reach out to support@fundraisersoftware.com Thank you.

 

  User Name:
  Password:

If you are not sure about your Customer User Name, please call 800-543-4131 and we will be able to help you.

Or you have lost your password, Request Password